| | Dr. Demento 25th Anniversary Collection CD DISC 1: |
| 1. | Smells Like Nirvana - Weird Al Yankovic |
| 2. | Heartbreak Hotel - Stan Freberg |
| 3. | Curly Shuffle, The - Jump 'N the Saddle Band |
| 4. | Rubber Biscuit - The Chips |
| 5. | Martian Boogie, The - Brownsville Station |
| 6. | Fast Food - Stevens and Grdnic |
| 7. | Car Phone - Sheeler & Sheeler |
| 8. | Highly Illogical - Leonard Nimoy |
| 9. | One More Minute - Weird Al Yankovic |
| 10. | No, I Don't Wanna Do Dat - Happy Schnapps Combo |
| 11. | Dance of the Hours - Spike Jones & His City Slickers |
| 12. | My Dead Dog Rover - Hank, Stu, Dave & Hank |
| 13. | There's a New Sound - Tony Burrello |
| 14. | When I Was a Dinosaur - Trout Fishing in America |
| 15. | Old Philosopher, The - Eddie "The Old Philosopher" Lawrence |
| 16. | Happy Boy - Beat Farmers |
| 17. | Tiptoe Through the Tulips With Me - Tiny Tim |
| 18. | Shaving Cream - Benny Bell |
| | Dr. Demento 25th Anniversary Collection Songs DISC 2: |
| 1. | Particle Man - They Might Be Giants |
| 2. | Sensitive New Age Guys - Christine Lavin |
| 3. | Hunting Song, The - Tom Lehrer (previously unreleased) |
| 4. | Achy Breaky Song - Weird Al Yankovic |
| 5. | In Heaven There Is No Beer - Clean Living |
| 6. | I Gotta Get a Fake I.D. - Barnes & Barnes |
| 7. | Peter the Meter Reader - Meri Wilson |
| 8. | Everybody Wants My Fanny - Benny Bell |
| 9. | Entering Marion - John Forster |
| 10. | 'Cause I'm a Blonde - Julie Brown |
| 11. | Leader of the Laundromat - The Detergents |
| 12. | Song of the Sewer - Art Carney |
| 13. | Mr. Custer - Larry Verne |
| 14. | Second Week of Deer Camp - Da Yoopers |
| 15. | Timothy - Buoys |
| 16. | Stardrek - Peter Ferrara/Bobby "Boris" Pickett/Peter Ferrara |
| 17. | Three Little Pigs - Green Jelly |
| 18. | Moose Turd Pie - Utah Phillips |