John Lennon - Some Time In New York City/Live Jam CD

 Awful
Easily, this is the worst solo Beatle album. Yoko's voice is terrible, and I don't care what any critic says. She really did not help Lennon's music in any way. The political songs have not aged well.
Submitted by pstairiker (Caldwell, NJ) 
Was This Review Helpful? Yes No  2 of 2 found this helpful.

 A rewritten moment in time
This album seems to be about a moment in time, more so than any of Lennon's others. The moment reflects Lennon's political interests circa 1972. There is certainly a "cringe" factor associated with listening to this album now-probably due to the fact that these songs were mostly about causes/ideas that didn't really have a long shelf life. The Yoko tracks-well, they were never the reason to buy a Lennon album. The Lennon tracks-well, we have all heard better from him. The good and the bad: The Mothers/Lennons' jam has been edited to just "Well (baby please don't go)". Missing is the semi-tedious, but momentary snicker-inducing "Scumbag/Jamrag/Au" jam (or as Frank Zappa titles part of it on his version of these proceedings as "A small eternity of Yoko Ono" available on his Playground Psychotics album). I'm all for listening to less of Yoko screach endlessly, but 2 things come to mind. One, a distinct part of the album was removed. Two, one of the bonus tracks, "Listen the snow is falling" -(collectable as a b-side I guess) is Yoko singing-(which is not that far removed from the sreaching anyway)-so we didn't gain much by editing/adding to this album. By the way, the "morphing" label from the LP, seems to have missed being put on this album. Believe it or not, it appears on the remastered Walls and Bridges album. Finally, for the first time on the cd jacket, the packaging reflects the LP's red sharpie marked-up Mother's Filmore East album jacket--even though the "Jamrag-Scumbag-Au" jam, while listed-is missing. I can only guess that Yoko is re-writting Lennon's history again for her own purposes. By, the way the re-mixed songs do sound better.
Submitted by orson (Westchester, NY, USA)
Was This Review Helpful? Yes No  2 of 2 found this helpful.

 This remix fixes alot that was wrong
I have the original vinyl release and the double CD that came out years ago. This album is a true diamond in the rough. I have never been a fan of the "wall of sound" production techniques of Phil Spector and the original mix was chock full of all that is wrong with that approach. It was a very dense, dry, claustrophobic sound. This remix fixes most of those problems. You will notice much more space in the mix. Each instrument is given it's own place. I could go on about hearing acoustic and electric guitar parts that were previously buried. The piano solo in "Angela" is a thing of beauty and it is lifted to it's rightful place in the center of the sound spectrum. EVERYTHING sounds better, cleaner and more lifelike. The remastering has seen to that. Even the two songs that were not remixed, "Attica State" and "John Sinclair" sound fresh and new. The slide guitar on "John Sinclair" is frankly, incredible. I even enjoy Yoko's songs much more. The backing tracks shine in this remix. Even the live tracks that originally made up the second LP sound much better. I actually can hear the brass section in "Don't worry, Kyoko" and it is unnoticeable in the original mix. This recording was viewed as a flop when originally released but I guarantee that a fresh listen with this new mix and remastering will make converts of everyone who takes the time to listen.
Submitted by Fritzopup (Worthington, Ohio, USA) 
Was This Review Helpful? Yes No  1 of 2 found this helpful.

Have you heard this album?